Paper type: Case Study
The Boston Case:
Boston and its GLX project form the first of six cases that we are tackling in order to understand how one can build public transportation more efficiently and less expensively. When choosing cases, we looked for a number of different variables to avoid drawing general conclusions from sui generis examples. These include the following:
– For the first American case, we wanted to avoid New York. The reason is that while American costs are generally high, New York’s are uniquely high, and therefore it is likely New York has an unusual set of failures not seen elsewhere in the country.
– Capital construction costs in Massachusetts have exploded over the last 40 years. While there hasn’t been any expansion of the existing network since the 1980s, we see in Table 1 that even after adjusting for inflation, GLX is only 6% cheaper per kilometer than the Red Line extension to Alewife, which is entirely underground and has deep, cavernous stations. The Orange Line project may be a better comparison because the majority of the project was at-grade, with a short tunnel under the Charles; GLX, without any tunneling, is more than twice as expensive per kilometer.

– We need excellent quantitative data in order to be able to see if there is a specific thing that went wrong. There is fairly uniform data reporting throughout the United States, but certain public-private partnerships like that of the Maryland Purple Line make it hard to disaggregate data.
– We need excellent qualitative data, that is access to many different experts and practitioners who could help us understand what is going on. For idiosyncratic reasons, we have better access to such sources in Boston than in the rest of the United States save New York and California.
– The history of GLX is dramatic: as we explain in more detail below, planning activities for GLX began in 2004 and continued through 2012. It underwent a cost explosion, and, in 2015, it was threatened with cancellation before it was rebooted with a new design, budget, and project delivery, leaving nearly $700 million of the old project’s budget as a sunk cost. Each of these periods in GLX’s story provide an opportunity to assess why costs diverged from expectations and how the MBTA salvaged GLX. Lessons learned here, will provide avenues of inquiry as we pursue future cases.
Rebuilding Bus Ridership in America
Bus ridership in cities across the United States is declining. In Brooklyn, New York, annual ridership has declined by nearly 50,000,000 rides between 2007 and 2017. While this 21% reduction in ridership is alarming, it isn’t impossible to reverse. Based on experiences in other cities around the world, namely Barcelona, we have proposed a radically specific redesign of the Brooklyn bus network that translates best practices from other cities into a plan for Brooklyn that consists of new route designs, greater service frequency, revamped street configurations, and fewer stops. Furthermore, we have limited our redesign to the existing operating hours budget provided by the Metropolitan Transportation Authority so that our redesign doesn’t ignore budgetary constraints. By making the bus faster, more reliable, and less vulnerable to traffic congestion, the bus can again be a mode of transit that stitches Brooklyn together and provides access to the promise of New York.
Forecasting and Risk Communication
FORECASTING AIR POLLUTION IN YOUR CITY
Air pollution estimates are made using satellite data, information about global emissions, advanced weather forecasting, state-of-the art chemical modeling, and machine learning to tailor the results to individual cities. The most important aspect of this information is that it can provide predictions of air pollution values for the next five days. These forecasts can help residents in your city know beforehand when severe pollution episodes will occur; help individuals make plans regarding their outdoor activities; and provide information to improve local air quality management decisions.
COMMUNICATION OF HEALTH RISKS
In addition to providing estimates of outdoor concentrations of multiple air pollutants (PM2.5, NO2, O3 and SO2) a health-based air quality index has also been created that can easily communicate the combined risks of multiple air pollutants on a day-to-day basis. These easy-to-understand values are particularly useful for individuals that are sensitive to outdoor air pollution such as people with asthma and other respiratory diseases.
TAILORING THE DATA TO YOUR CITY
Air pollution and risk communication index values can be further tailored to the specific conditions in your city if you provide additional local data to the NASA and NYU project team. Sharing data is not required to access the forecasted pollution values and health-based air quality index. However, it can help improve the usefulness of the forecasts for your city. Three examples are provided on the next page to illustrate how sharing data helped to improve the specificity of air pollution and risk communication information for individual cities.