Paper type: Paper

Eye in the Sky:

Illegal parking poses significant challenges in urban environments, obstructing travel lanes, increasing gridlock, and blocking access to critical infrastructure. This study aims to examine how police respond to illegal parking complaints in New York City, offering a first-of-its-kind, systematic, large-scale analysis of law enforcement patterns, with significant policy implications. We used artificial intelligence and a network of publicly available camera feeds operated by the New York City Department of Transportation (DOT) to monitor and file complaints and subsequently track and assess enforcement patterns. Over five days, 558 illegal parking complaints were generated across 21 cameras, with at least one in each of the city’s five boroughs. The New York Police Department (NYPD) closed 291 complaints (52.15 %) while vehicles were still parked illegally and reported issuing only 16 tickets (2.87 %) during the observation period. Certain areas exhibited chronic illegal parking issues that persisted despite repeated complaints. Official resolutions often contradicted ground truth captured by DOT cameras, highlighting discrepancies in enforcement reporting. These findings empirically validate a widely recognized but previously anecdotal phenomenon in New York City: the persistent lack of NYPD enforcement against illegal parking. The results strengthen the case for increased automated ticketing systems, enhanced police oversight, and street designs that inherently discourage such violations.

Read the Article

The Essential Role of Air Quality Monitoring

The U.S. Department of State has discontinued public reporting of air quality data frommonitors deployed at U.S. embassies and consulates worldwide. Starting with the first embassymonitor in 2008, and rapidly expanding following the launch of the DOSAir program in 2015,this global network has been an invaluable resource, providing real-time air quality informationin many locations where no other reliable pollution monitoring exists or is not publicly reported(1). While these monitors have greatly benefited the local communities where they operate,this discussion focuses on the direct benefits to U.S. citizens—those living abroad and thoseresiding in the United States.

Nearly all of the expenses of the State Department’s air monitoring program are associatedwith the initial purchase of American-made air pollution monitoring equipment, and these costshave been more than directly offset by reductions in post hardship differential payments topersonnel stationed abroad (2). Ongoing maintenance expenses are relatively modest, on theorder of thousands of dollars per year, and represent a small investment given the substantialfinancial and operational benefits the program provides.

There are three primary ways these monitors have served American interests:

1. Protecting U.S. citizens abroad by providing critical air quality data for health andsafety;

2. Prompting foreign governments to take stronger pollution control actions, leading toemissions reductions that directly benefit the U.S.;

3. Providing essential ground-truth data that supports U.S. financial and scientificinvestments in air quality models and satellite systems.

Read the Article

A community health worker-delivered intervention

The objective of this study is to evaluate an intervention designed to reduce human trafficking among Denotified Tribes (DNTs) in two regions of India. We will conduct a cluster-randomized controlled trial utilizing a participatory-designed, community health worker (CHW)- delivered public health intervention. CHWs will be trained to conduct anti-human-trafficking advocacy and psychological first aid (humane, supportive and practical assistance to people who are distressed) to DNT community members, and mobilize resources to ensure access to health and mental health services, education, livelihoods, and government benefits. This project leverages known effective, systemic, and sustainable approaches to reducing vulnerabilities to trafficking among DNT communities, through increased economic alternatives, health and mental health services guided by the trafficking-survivor-informed treatment protocols.

Estimating Reporting Bias in 311 Compliant Data

Resident-generated data1 consists of data that are intentionally created by individuals for accessible use by policy-makers and the public, for purposes including improved governance and more responsive public services (Meijer and Potjer, 2018). For example, many cities now have “311” systems through which residents can report on their environments, request information, and request non-emergency municipal services through phone calls, texts, web, or other communication modalities (City of New York, 2021). Increasingly, such resident-generated data are used to help make policy decisions and allocate resources, and can be used as data for machine learning models incorporated into automated tools for policy decision support (City of New Orleans, 2019).

Here we focus on New York City’s 311 system (NYC 311) (City of New York, 2021), which receives more than 8,000,000 resident-generated reports annually (Kontokosta et al., 2017; Zha and Veloso, 2014; Nadeau, 2011). Of these reports, approximately 20% can be considered a “complaint” about city services or conditions, which require additional follow up by the relevant city agency (Nadeau, 2011). Our research focuses on residential heating and water issues in NewYorkCity. NYC’sDepartmentofHousingPreservationandDevelop ment (HPD), the agency responsible for monitoring housing conditions in NYC, inspects and subsequently issues violations for inadequate heating and hot water at building level. Resi dential building inspections primarily occur after a 311 complaint is filed through NYC’s 311 system, stating that at least one residential unit in the building is experiencing a heating and hot water problem.

Despite recent work to increase the accessibility of NYC 311 (Minkoff, 2016), there is a concern that these data are biased due to systematic differences in residents’ propensity to report a problem (Kontokosta and Hong, 2021; McLafferty, Schneider and Abelt, 2020). Therefore, using resident-generated data at face value to fit decision support tools, without interrogating potential data biases, can result in misallocation of community services and resources, and can further reinforce societal biases which may harm under-served popula tions. These biases are potentially exacerbated because most of New York City’s building inspections are conducted reactively, in response to 311 resident complaints, and therefore a problem that is not reported to 311 is both less likely to be observed in the data, and less likely to be addressed in a timely manner by the city. Thus, identifying under-reporting areas and subpopulations could assist policy-makers in reaching out to these groups to ensure that their housing issues are addressed.

Heating and hot water problems are serious quality-of-life issues which represent the largest category of NYC 311 complaints (35.9% of total complaints). As such, there is a critical need to understand geographic and demographic disparities both in the frequency of these problems, and the probability that they are reported to the city via 311. However, ob taining an unbiased ground truth of heating and hot water issues would require some form of resident surveys, ubiquitous sensing (e.g., Internet of Things), or inspections throughout all or a large random sample of buildings. These solutions are costly, and they often suffer from common survey sampling errors (Kelly and Swindell, 2002) or are nascent initiatives that are inconsistently deployed and unevenly distributed (Kontokosta, 2016; Zheng et al., 2014). Without reliable “gold standard” data, previous studies such as Minkoff (2016) and White and Trump (2018) identify geographic and demographic variability in 311 complaints but are unable to distinguish whether this variation is due to differences in reporting, differences in the underlying rates of problems, or a combination of the two.

Here we address the challenge of estimating under-reporting in 311 data using two dis tinct and novel methodological approaches. Our first approach estimates “non-reporting”, in which a building has a heating or hot water problem during the legally mandated heating period, but no resident of the building places a 311 call about that problem. In this case, we have no record in the 311 call log that such a problem has occurred, making it impossible to distinguish whether that particular building failed to report its problem or simply did not have a problem to report. Nevertheless, when aggregating data across many buildings in neighbor hoods throughout a city, we can estimate the expected frequency of problems conditional on building characteristics, and use this information to estimate the “non-reporting” rate for different neighborhoods and neighborhood-level demographic characteristics. To accomplish this, we design a latent variable model which we fit with expectation-maximization to esti mate the distribution of underlying unreported heating and hot water problems. We then use this model to identify which neighborhood socioeconomic characteristics are associated with non-reporting.

Our second methodological approach estimates “less-than-expected” reporting. When a building places at least one 311 call for a given problem in a given heating season, we can both observe the total number of calls placed as well as estimate the duration of that problem based on the timing of those calls. This allows us to ask a different question: conditional on a problem having occurred and at least one 311 call being placed, and controlling for building size (number of residential units) and problem duration, which buildings are placing a lower-than-expected number of calls? To achieve this, we define groupings of buildings of similar size, experiencing a similar length of heating and hot water problems, and rank the normalized call volumes (311 calls per unit per day) within each grouping. We reaggre gate these buildings by neighborhood and test whether each neighborhood has a significantly higher than expected proportion of less-than-expected reporting buildings, adjusting for mul tiple testing and controlling the overall False Discovery Rate. Furthermore, we fit a linear regression model to determine which neighborhood-level socioeconomic characteristics are associated with less-than-expected reporting.

We apply these methods for estimating “non-reporting” and “less-than-expected report ing” in conjunction, and observe that they provide highly consistent results regarding which neighborhoods and subpopulations are under-reporting their heating and hot water problems to 311.

The contributions of this work include:

1. We define a taxonomy for under-reporting, and separate analysis approaches for non reporting and less-than-expected reporting, which can be easily adapted to a variety of other real-world scenarios, such as crime reporting.

2. To our knowledge, we are the first to develop a latent variable model for reporting bias in 311 complaints. This model integrates both attributes which are assumed independent of reporting behaviors (structural building characteristics) and attributes which are associated with the propensity to report (socioeconomic characteristics) to estimate a distribution of the latent variable, i.e., underlying heating and hot water problems.

3. We integrate domain knowledge about the 311 system in our modeling logic to estimate non-reporting and exploit the nuances of the 311 complaint data schema to estimate less than-expected reporting.

4. Our analyses provide actionable information about NYC neighborhoods with a higher density of under-reporting and neighborhood-level socioeconomic characteristics which are associated with under-reporting, which can help government and advocacy agencies improve accessibility to 311 and reduce the impacts of unreported heating and hot water problems in New York City.

The remainder of the paper proceeds as follows: Section 2 describes the NYC 311 data used for analysis and our methods for estimating non-reporting and less-than-expected re porting. The results of applying these methods to the NYC 311 data are presented in Sec tion 3, and Section 4 contains a concluding discussion.

Prioritizing Politics Ahead of Transit Projects

In the span of five years, the Federal Transit Administration’s (FTA) New Starts capital grant program expanded from just over one billion dollars in Fiscal Year 2019 to nearly four and a half billion dollars in Fiscal Year 2024. The Bipartisan Infrastructure Law, more broadly, authorizes as much as $108 billion in Federal support for public transportation through Fiscal Year 2026. With more money available for capital projects than ever before, it is critical that this money be spent well and develop projects that contribute to decarbonizing the transportation sector, promote compatible land-use goals, and improve access within and between American cities.

As exciting as the opportunity ahead of us is, there is concern that it is too difficult and expensive to build large-scale, transformative infrastructure projects in the United States in the 21st century. In the media, Klein, Gordon, Demsas, and many, many others have lamented large infrastructure projects’ soaring costs and extended timelines. Flyvbjerg argues that large infrastructure projects, megaprojects, are defined both by their large initial cost estimates that give them their name, but also by their tendency to be over budget, behind schedule, and produce fewer benefits than promised. Making this more urgent in the United States, Goldwyn et al.’s Transit Cost Project found that in a sample of 883 rapid rail projects across 57 countries plus Taiwan and Hong Kong, the United States had the eighth highest costs per kilometer in Purchasing Power Parity adjusted 2023 dollars. This reading of the data omits the key fact that in the United States only 34% of projects in the database are tunneled, the most expen-sive rapid rail construction method, while the eight countries with higher per kilometer costs build 65% or more of their projects in tunnels. Addi-tionally, the current group of projects in the development pipeline in the United States, such as Phase 2 of the Second Avenue Subway, Gateway Tunnel Project, Transbay Downtown Rail Extension, West Seattle to Ballard Link Extension, and the BART extension to San Jose have higher absolute costs and per kilometer costs than their predecessors.

In this paper, I argue that these mounting costs and delays are the product of prioritizing politics ahead of transit projects. Alan Altshuler and David Luberoff explain that over the last 60 years it has become increasingly difficult to carry out disruptive projects in the United States: “the capacity of local growth coalitions to impose disruption on other local interests sharply—and durably-declined in the late 1960s and early 1970s.” Nuno Gil approaches this issue from a different vantage point. He argues, rather, that impacted stakeholders, often “nonmarket actors” such as municipal agencies, require tangible value from megaprojects in order to allow them to proceed. In practice this “value distribution” is negotiated and renegotiated as political and funding commitments become firmer rather than at the outset when so much is still unknown. This ongoing uncertainty leads to larger project scopes, schedule slippage, and higher costs over time. For transit projects, this do no harm principle or expansive value distribution framework adds costs and diminishes project benefits, when viewed through the lens of faster travel times and greater ridership, when agencies site a transit project in a less convenient freight railroad right-of-way rather than condemning private land, use federal grants to pay for elements beyond the needs of a transit project to gain needed permits, adopt more expensive designs to limit third party interfaces, and placate different powerbrokers, including elected officials, utility companies, transit agency operating entities, and others while undercutting traditional planning, design, cost estimating, and project management.

Methodologically, I rely on quantitative and qualitative methods to describe and explain why American rapid rail transit costs are higher than global averages. I draw on quantitative evidence to develop key descriptive statistics, namely a global weighted average of rapid rail projects per kilometer, and contextualize global rail transit project costs to show how American projects exceed international averages. Next, I take an in-depth look at two recently completed domestic transit projects, Phase 1 of the Second Avenue Subway in New York and the Green Line Extension in Massachusetts. I examine planning documents, official reports, historical accounts, media coverage, and the megaproject and project management literatures to understand the development and shortcomings of specific projects. Additionally, I have conducted more than 170 semi-structured interviews with elected officials, agency staff, consultants, contractors, laborers, and others familiar with specific projects and the broader transportation industry including transit and mainline rail projects in Massachusetts, New York, California, Utah, Oregon, Maryland, Texas, Florida, and Washington. I show how project sponsors struggle to define their project’s purpose clearly; thus, never finding firm footing in the project development or construction phases, and how forces within and beyond agencies’ control knock them off their course. I conclude by sharing some good news: it is possible to build these projects faster and cheaper, as they do in Spain, South Korea, Turkey, Italy, Chile, and Sweden, but it requires changing our priorities and nurturing the expertise to plan, design, and manage rapid rail transit projects.

A Multi-Dimensional Access Index:

Access to resources and services needs to be considered from a multi-dimensional perspective to capture the complex landscape of human experience. The robust body of research exploring food access has multiple limitations that create an incomplete view of food access, like studies limited to only one mode of transit and inconsistent methods across studies which limit generalizability. This study proposes a framework to formulate a multi-dimensional access index that considers travel time, operating hours, and availability of transit infrastructure across space. We use food pantries in New York City as a case study since there are relatively few of them and they have limited opening hours. We propose an index that quantifies spatiotemporal access by different modes of transportation and takes operating hours of food pantries into account during a one week time period. We compare our results to two traditional access measures and demonstrate that our index provides a significantly different measure of access. We utilize this index to highlight areas of high need but low resources, which shows the importance of this tool to policy makers and service providers. We use our experience of developing this index to highlight the challenges with quantitative analysis of human experience. Our tool is reproducible through an open-access software, which allows researchers and policy-makers to utilize it with parameters that reflect their communities.

read the article

Human Trafficking Risk Factors, Health Impacts

Background

Human trafficking is a global public health issue that is associated with serious short- and long-term morbidity. To address and prevent human trafficking, vulnerabilities to human trafficking and forces sustaining it need to be better understood among specific subpopulations. We aimed to explore risk and protective factors for human trafficking, the health impact of exploitation, and barriers and facilitators of seeking help throughout the human trafficking trajectory among forced labor and sex trafficking victims in Kampala, Uganda.

Methods

Between March and November 2020, in-depth, semi-structured qualitative interviews were conducted with 108 victims of forced labor and sex trafficking who had completed a human trafficking survey conducted by the Uganda Youth Development Link (UYDEL). Participants who experienced various forms of exploitation were purposively invited for qualitative interviews and a convenience sample was interviewed. Interviews explored personal history, trafficking recruitment, experiences of exploitation and abuse, and experiences seeking help. Interviews were analyzed using a combination of deductive and inductive thematic analysis. Themes and subthemes were organized using an adapted conceptual framework of human trafficking.

Results

Poverty and an abusive home life, frequently triggered by the death of a caretaker, underpinned vulnerability to human trafficking recruitment. Limited education, lack of social support, and survival needs pushed victims into exploitative situations. Victims of human trafficking were systematically exploited and exposed to dangerous working conditions. Victims suffered from sexually transmitted diseases, incontinence, traumatic fistulae, musculoskeletal injuries, and mental health symptoms. Lack of awareness of resources, fear of negative consequences, restrictions on movement, and dependence on the trafficker and exploitation income prevented victims from seeking help. The police and healthcare workers were the few professionals that they interacted with, but these interactions were oftentimes negative experiences.

Conclusions

To address and prevent human trafficking, localized interventions are needed at all stages of the human trafficking trajectory. Health impacts of human trafficking are severe. As some of the few professionals trafficking victims interact with, police and healthcare workers are important targets for anti-trafficking training. Improved understanding of human trafficking drivers and barriers and facilitators to seeking help can inform the design of necessary interventions.

read the article

Socio-Spatial Inequality and the Effects

Cities are often associated with the rapid spread of infectious diseases, driven by the perceived risks of urban density and overcrowding. However, transmission risk can vary considerably within urbanized areas as a function of socio-spatial disparities and the adoption of mitigating behaviors across communities. Here we examine the effect of density on coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) infection rates at the neighborhood scale, within and across US cities. We integrate high-spatial resolution measures of land use and residential population density, mobility, infection rates and social determinants of health to evaluate the impact of neighborhood context on infection risk, while controlling for the potential mitigating effects of social distancing behavior. We are particularly focused on disparities among marginalized and vulnerable neighborhoods, and the generalizability of the results across political, socioeconomic, regional and built environment contexts. Our findings demonstrate a nonlinear relationship between urban density and infection rates, with higher-density neighborhoods more likely to adopt mitigating behaviors to reduce transmission. However, low-income and minority communities, facing cascading health challenges, are found to be least able to modify mobility behavior and therefore experienced a disproportionate burden of COVID-19 infection risk during the first wave of the pandemic.

Read the article

Adverse Health Impacts of Outdoor Air Pollution

Rationale: Adverse health impacts from outdoor air pollution occur across the U.S., but the magnitude of these impacts varies widely by geographic region. Ambient pollutant concentrations, emission sources, baseline health conditions, and population sizes and distributions are all important factors that need to be taken into account to quantify local health burdens. Objective: To determine health impacts from ambient air pollution concentrations in the U.S. that exceed recommended levels from the American Thoracic Society (ATS). Methods: Using a methodology that has been well established in previous “Health of the Air” reports, this study provides policy-relevant estimates for every monitored county and city in the U.S. for the adverse health impacts of outdoor pollution concentrations, using Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) design values for years 2018–2020. Additionally, for the first time, the report includes adverse birth outcomes as well as estimates of health impacts specifically attributable to wildland fires using an exposure dataset generated through Community Multi-scale Air Quality (CMAQ) simulations. Results: The adverse health burdens attributable to air pollution occur across the entire age spectrum, including adverse birth outcomes (10,660 preterm and/or low weight births; 95% CI: 3,180–18,330), in addition to mortality impacts (21,300 avoidable deaths; 95% CI: 16,150–26,200), lung cancer incidence (3,000 new cases; 95% CI: 1,550–4,390), multiple types of cardiovascular and respiratory morbidity (748,660 events; 95% CI: 326,050–1,057,080), and adversely impacted days (52.4 million days; 95% CI: 7.9–92.4 million). Two different estimates of mortality impacts from wildland fires were estimated based on assumptions regarding the underlying toxicity of particles from wildland fires (low estimate of 4,080 deaths, 95% CI: 240–7,890; middle estimate of 28,000 deaths, 95% CI: 27,300–28,700). Conclusions – This year’s report identified sizable health benefits that are expected to occur across the U.S. from meeting more health-protective air quality standards such as those recommended by ATS. This study also indicates that a large number of excess deaths are attributable to emissions from wildland fires; air quality management strategies outside what is required by the Clean Air Act will be needed to best address this important source of air pollution and its associated health risks. Primary Source of Funding: National Aeronautics and Space Administration, Environmental Defense Fund

Read the Paper

First Ever Study on Youth Forced Labor in Uganda

Children and youth in Uganda are susceptible to forced labor. To gain insight into their lived experiences, we employed an explanatory sequential mixed methods framework, administering 530 surveys then interviewing a subset of 36 survey takers. Through the lens of child standpoint theory, we examined participant demographics, type of work and entry points, abuse, and help seeking/barriers to leaving. Key findings include the following: 1) Participant demographics were largely males under 17 years; 2) parental death and socioeconomic strain in the home led to participant’s vulnerability to forced labor; 3) participants frequently begged and/or sold food or goods, collected scrap metal, bottles, or plastic; 4) employers (exploiters) were mostly parents, other family members, or others that children encounter in Kampala; 5) abuse ranged from physical, sexual, verbal, financial and psychological at the hands of employers, individuals on the streets, and authorities; and 6) participants avoided reporting abuse to authorities for lack of trust, fear of employer, or unawareness of how/where to report. We argue for child/youth-centered research and the training of stakeholders on youth and children’s rights and protections, more funding for child welfare programming and the institution of mandated laws, policies, procedures, resources, coordination and enforcement mechanisms aimed at reducing child forced labor.