Paper type: Report
Go Local! Nurturing Neighborhoods and Advancing
Despite decades of success by place-based non-profits like BIDs and parks groups in reviving commercial corridors and public spaces, the fact remains that smaller BIDs face profound challenges. These smaller entities, which now constitute two-thirds of all BIDs, are difficult to create and sustain in less-resourced neighborhoods.
Meanwhile, the City’s needs and ambitions with respect to public space and neighborhood-led economic vibrancy have only increased, even as it faces fiscal strains due to reduced income and property tax forecasts.
Specifically, the Making New York Work for Everyone action plan, released in December 2022, identified a number of initiatives to improve quality of life, expand public space, and create a more vibrant and equitable economy. And in February 2023, Mayor Adams announced the historic appointment of the City’s first-ever Chief Public Realm Officer to help coordinate public realm projects that will improve and expand public space and help with our city’s post-pandemic recovery.
Tapping and expanding the network of small BIDs and similar place-based non-profits would be an easy way for the City to achieve these goals, especially in areas that have historically lacked investment.
Yet a mix of factors limit the potential of these smaller neighborhood-based partners to sustain, innovate and serve as stewards for the public realm and their local economy:
- Bureaucratic barriers, however well-intentioned originally, strangle innovation and eliminate the ability to participate, leaving private sector resources and energy on the table.
- Direct technical and financial support from the City to support local capacity is insufficient, given the scale of need in economically challenged areas.
- The BID financing model has not incorporated new ways of creating, capturing, and keeping community wealth to address long-standing inequities.
To enable and empower BIDs and community partners so that they can sustain themselves, their districts, and the City’s equity goals, the City must:
Reduce the pain points and trust community partners
The City needs to reduce or remove administrative burdens that effectively eliminate the ability of smaller groups with limited capacity to support their districts.
This includes addressing major challenges like insurance requirements and concessions, but also day-to-day challenges like event permitting and easy, free access to power and water.
The City also needs to create a Trusted Partner Program which frees and empowers BIDs with a track record of success from the myriad of duplicative and adversarial requirements which effectively knock small BIDs out of the box.
Develop capacity to support place-based partnerships
The City needs to more effectively address public realm needs by building capacity for both City government and external partners.
This includes creating a Public Realm Task Force to explore short- and long- term ways to:
- Empower, support and better coordinate the agencies and allies within government that support community partners like BIDs
- Reduce and simplify redundant and restrictive regulatory, contractual and bureaucratic burdens that hold partners back
- Pilot an equity-driven BID creation process in less resourced areas
In addition, per the Making New York Work for Everyone action plan recommendation #13, create a genuinely independent but affiliated citywide non-profit which can help SBS and DOT support their public space partners.
Explore funding tools to capture the value created by place-based partners to increase equity across the city
The City must explore new options to ensure that smaller BIDs and less resourced neighborhoods are able to sustain and take advantage of the value created through public realm and commercial corridor activation and improvements.
This includes encouraging greater use of residential assessments, which are already becoming more common in New York.
It also means looking both within and beyond New York at tools and tactics which could help small BIDs, such as:
- Direct government support through grants or contracts for services
- Channeling funds and support through intermediary non-profits
- Looking at value capture and community wealth building tools which retain some portion of impact fees, cross-subsidies, tax increment financing, license or parking fees and land ownership within targeted communities
Risk Adverse and Disinclined:
This report examines the challenges and opportunities that states faced in deciding whether to release people from prison during the COVID-19 pandemic. It focuses on the legal mechanisms available to jurisdictions and the factors that influenced whether they were willing or able to use those mechanisms to release people from prison.
Our goal is to illuminate whether back-end release mechanisms can be used to reduce prison populations that have been bloated by the policies of the mass-incarceration era or whether relief from mass incarceration must take some other form.
The report presents case studies of six states—Alabama, Illinois, Kansas, Minnesota, Pennsylvania, and Washington—to gain a more in-depth view of how events unfolded during the pandemic. Overall, our study found that the number of individuals released early from prisons during the pandemic was limited due to a variety of factors, including politics, risk-averse decision-making, shifting external pressures, the limited scope of compassionate and medical release statutes and the use of discretion to deny release. In addition, few changes to policy or practice that occurred during the pandemic had a lasting impact on back-end release practices.
We conclude that the back-end release mechanisms offer only a modest opportunity to reduce mass incarceration, and the current system is unlikely to make a substantial difference in addressing mass incarceration due primarily to risk aversion. Instead, state-level carceral policies that focus on diffusing responsibility for back-end release and that reduce incarceration in the first place have the greatest chance of achieving long-term reductions in prison populations.
Realizing the Promise of Crime Victim Compensation
Established by Congress in 1984, Crime Victim Compensation (CVC) is a federal and state program designed to reimburse victims for certain out-of-pocket expenses resulting from their victimization. In recent years, there has been a growing recognition of the unique challenges faced by victims of community violence when accessing CVC. This increased attention has prompted efforts to reform and enhance the program, including a review of CVC’s guidelines initiated by the Office for Victims of Crime, the federal administrators of CVC.
In “Realizing the Promise of Crime Victim Compensation,” the Marron Institute aims to provide support for these ongoing initiatives. Drawing from a national examination of CVC’s laws and policies, “Realizing the Promise” offers detailed recommendations that can be used by advocates, community violence-intervention programs, and government leaders to unlock the program’s potential in aiding victims in their recovery, addressing trauma, and promoting resilience within affected communities.
South African Women Entrepreneurs
Throughout Africa, women-led enterprises emerge and persist despite daunting challenges: struggles to secure resources and access to markets.¹ Given the role of women entrepreneurs as employers and as engines of economic growth across the continent, it is important to understand their strengths as well as the challenges they confront, to learn how best to support them as business leaders during and post-COVID-19. Efforts to foster resilience among women-led enterprises in Africa have faced a widely recognized problem—unreliable data.² Lionesses of Africa is partnering with researchers from New York University to provide reliable, timely data and insights into women entrepreneurs and their businesses and give Africa’s women entrepreneurs a voice in shaping resources targeted to them.
This first report in the series focuses on South Africa’s women entrepreneurs. Women account for just 19.4% of business owners in South Africa³ but have made important gains in recent years in entrepreneurial activity.⁴ This report describes the experiences of South Africa’s women entrepreneurs through key insights derived from data collected from the South African Women Entrepreneurs Job Creators Survey.
New Report on Health Impacts from Wildland Fires
Wildland fires are diminishing air quality on a seasonal and regional basis, raising concerns about respiratory health risks to the public and occupational groups. This American Thoracic Society (ATS) workshop was convened in 2019 to meet the growing health threat of wildland fire smoke. The workshop brought together a multi-disciplinary group of 19 experts, including wildland fire managers, public health officials, epidemiologists, toxicologists, and pediatric and adult pulmonologists. The workshop examined four major topics: (1) the science of wildland fire incidence and fire management, (2) the respiratory and cardiovascular health effects of wildland fire smoke exposure, (3) communication strategies to address these health risks, and (4) actions to address wildland fire health impacts. Through formal presentations followed by group discussion, workshop participants identified top priorities for fire management, research, communication and public policy to address health risks of wildland fires. The workshop concluded that short-term exposure to wildland smoke causes acute respiratory health effects, especially among those with asthma and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD). Research is needed to understand long-term health effects of repeated smoke exposures across fire seasons for children, adults and highly exposed occupational groups (especially firefighters). Other research priorities include fire data collection and modeling, toxicology of different fire fuel sources, and the efficacy of health protective measures to prevent respiratory effects of smoke exposure. The workshop committee recommends a unified Federal response to the growing problem of wildland fires, including investment in fire behavior and smoke air quality modeling, research on the health impacts of smoke, and the development of robust clinical and public health communication tools.
Effective Reentry Partnerships
Correctional agencies and their partners in the community can provide vital support to help curtail the spread of the coronavirus by safely reducing the incarcerated population with appropriate support. They can also maintain system legitimacy by supporting crime victims and addressing the harm done by crimes.
But as governments face new fiscal constraints, resources will need to be reallocated to support the most effective ways of addressing these new public safety and public health challenges. To that end, this brief from the Alliance for Safety and Justice and the Litmus program at the Marron Institute of Urban Management at New York University summarizes key information about a new federal funding stream that could strengthen the reentry and crime-survivors services continuum that corrections depends on.
This brief: 1. Summarizes how new U.S. Justice Department funds are available, and can be used to address new reentry challenges and address the needs of crime victims; 2. Highlights how strengthening partnerships with community-serving programs can help address new correctional challenges; and 3. Details what steps corrections leaders can take to ensure that federal dollars for reentry are used effectively through local and state public safety planning processes.
Recommendations for Rapid Release and Reentry
People who live and work in jails, prisons, and detention facilities are at elevated risk for SARS-CoV-2 infection, due to close living environments and the high prevalence of pre-existing health conditions. Agencies will be forced, through executive direction, litigation, or necessity (due to rising infections, lack of staff, or medical capacity) to release people in their custody early and to fast-track their usual reentry processes and services. Jails and prisons are beginning to release people. They will need to release many thousands more, or many may die.
The Litmus program at the NYU Marron Institute was working on early release from prison prior to COVID-19. In December 2019, the team completed a three-year pilot project (called Graduated Reintegration) that entailed releasing prisoners six months prior to their earned-release date, paired with substantial community supports, in collaboration with the Illinois Department of Corrections. A great deal was learned about early release from prison from this work, including the mechanisms that can allow early release and the challenges reentrants face. Many states will need to consider early release to reduce the density of their prison populations to lower the risk of COVID-19 spread, which makes the NYU Marron team’s experience of doing this in practice highly relevant.
Since early March 2020, Litmus has been working with justice agencies nationwide to learn how corrections (jails and prisons) and community corrections (probation and parole) are responding to COVID-19. Over a four-week period, the team hosted five protocol-sharing sessions (including over 100 criminal justice system practitioners, from over twenty states). These sessions have yielded early insights into what agencies are doing (and not doing!) to curb the spread among these vulnerable groups—justice-involved people and public-safety officers, court officers, and mental health/drug treatment providers.
Prisoners who are released will face unprecedented challenges presented by COVID-19, including obtaining necessities such as food and shelter, accessing healthcare and behavioral healthcare, and entering a job market with historically high unemployment. Scattershot approaches to releasing prisoners, without substantial accompanying supports, will diminish prospects for succeeding in the community and may undermine future criminal justice reform efforts.
The assumptions and recommendations outlined in this report draw on the lessons we learned from our early-release pilot in Illinois and from practitioners who have attended our protocol-sharing sessions. They provide guidance to agencies supporting rapid release from incarceration and community reentry in response to COVID-19 and, in the foreseeable future, facing budget shortfalls.
The New York City Teachers’ Retirement System
Marron Collaborators Don Boyd*, Gang Chen*, and Yimeng Yin* examine fiscal issues and risks related to the New York City Teachers’ Retirement System (TRS). TRS is the second-largest of New York City’s five major retirement systems, as measured by assets. City contributions to TRS were approximately $3.7 billion in 2018, or 6 percent of tax revenue.
TRS has two important characteristics that set it apart from most other public pension plans in the nation. First, like other New York City pension plans, its contribution policy is more conservative than the typical public plan in the sense that city contributions rise relatively rapidly in response to investment shortfalls. This protects the solvency of the pension plan. The trade-off is greater risk to the city budget of sharp contribution increases in short time periods, relative to other commonly used contribution policies.
Second, in addition to their regular retirement benefit TRS members may contribute to a Tax-Deferred Annuity (TDA) program that offers guaranteed fixed returns backed by the defined benefit pension fund and thus by city taxpayers. The guaranteed rate for most members is 7 percent, set by the state legislature. It is well above guaranteed fixed returns that may be purchased in the private market, which are currently around 2 to 2.5 percent or less. TDA assets are invested by TRS along with regular defined benefit pension assets. The guarantee provides valuable benefits to plan members but creates special risks to the city. It does not have the constitutional protection that the regular retirement benefit has and therefore is more directly under the control of state and city policymakers.
If TDA assets earn more than the guarantee, the additional earnings accrue to the TRS pension fund, keeping city contributions funded by taxpayers lower than they otherwise might be. If TDA assets earn less than the guarantee, the pension fund must make up the difference, increasing costs to the city and its taxpayers.
Stock market declines of recent weeks due to COVID-19 illustrate the potential risk to city taxpayers. If TDA assets fall short of the guarantee by 10 percent – for example, if TRS were to lose approximately 3 percent in 2020 — then TRS will have to make up the difference. TDA had approximately $25 billion of assets at the end of 2019, so this would mean a guarantee payment of approximately $2.5 billion, ultimately funded by city taxpayers.
City policymakers need to understand the risks that City pension funds create, and make informed decisions about those risks. This report provides valuable information that will help them understand those risks.
* State and Local Government Finance Project, The Center for Policy Research, Rockefeller College, the University at Albany.
Urban Science
Urban science seeks to understand the fundamental processes that drive, shape and sustain cities and urbanization. It is a multi/transdisciplinary approach involving concepts, methods and research from the social, natural, engineering and computational sciences, along with the humanities. This report is intended to convey the current “state of the art” in urban science while also clearly indicating how urban science builds upon and complements (but does not replace) prior work on cities and urbanization in many other disciplines. The report does not aim at a fully comprehensive synopsis of work done under the rubric of “urban science” but it does aim to convey what makes urban science different from discipline-based examinations of cities and urbanization. It also highlights novel insights generated by the inherently multidisciplinary inquiry that urban science exemplifies. The authors of the report are all based in academic or research institutions but several of them are close to practice by virtue of collaboration with NGOs and community groups and engagement with policy. The authors also represent different academic disciplines and varied traditions of scientific inquiry. The report is meant to facilitate, and hopefully also provoke, discussion among the many stakeholders for whom a scientifically based, empirically rich, and historically deep understanding of cities and urbanization is not only intellectually compelling but also socially urgent and ethically pressing. We believe that the innovative scholarship constituting urban science can importantly provide scientific leadership to support meeting the urgent challenges of global sustainable development.
Authors: Lobo, Jose and Alberti, Marina and Allen-Dumas, Melissa and Arcaute, Elsa and Barthelemy, Marc and Bojorquez Tapia, Luis A. and Brail, Shauna and Bettencourt, Luis and Beukes, Anni and Chen, Wei‐Qiang and Florida, Richard and Gonzalez, Marta and Grimm, Nancy and Hamilton, Marcus and Kempes, Chris and Kontokosta, Constantine E. and Mellander, Charlotta and Neal, Zachary P. and Ortman, Scott and Pfeiffer, Deirdre and Price, Michael and Revi, Aromar and Rozenblat, Céline and Rybski, Diego and Siemiatycki, Matthew and Shutters, Shade T. and Smith, Michael E. and Stokes, Eleanor C. and Strumsky, Deborah and West, Geoffrey and White, Devin and Wu, Jingle and Yang, Vicky Chuqiao and York, Abigail and Youn, Hyejin
The Need for Public Bathrooms
This booklet highlights the importance of public bathrooms in the public realm, especially in improving public health and promoting human rights. We summarize research compiled over the course of a year from our readings, interviews, meetings, and analysis related to public bathrooms. We hope this booklet will serve as a resource for citizens, advocates, architects, urban planners, elected officials, government agencies, local business owners, and others to understand the benefits of public bathrooms, in the hope that we can increase the number of available facilities in our city.