Program: Civic Analytics

Exposure density and neighborhood disparities

Exposure density and neighborhood disparities in COVID-19 infection risk

PNAS 

March 30, 2021 118 (13) e2021258118

Although there is increasing awareness of disparities in COVID-19 infection risk among vulnerable communities, the effect of behavioral interventions at the scale of individual neighborhoods has not been fully studied. We develop a method to quantify neighborhood activity behaviors at high spatial and temporal resolutions and test whether, and to what extent, behavioral responses to social-distancing policies vary with socioeconomic and demographic characteristics. We define exposure density as a measure of both the localized volume of activity in a defined area and the proportion of activity occurring in distinct land-use types. Using detailed neighborhood data for New York City, we quantify neighborhood exposure density using anonymized smartphone geolocation data over a 3-mo period covering more than 12 million unique devices and rasterize granular land-use information to contextualize observed activity. Next, we analyze disparities in community social distancing by estimating variations in neighborhood activity by land-use type before and after a mandated stay-at-home order. Finally, we evaluate the effects of localized demographic, socioeconomic, and built-environment density characteristics on infection rates and deaths in order to identify disparities in health outcomes related to exposure risk. Our findings demonstrate distinct behavioral patterns across neighborhoods after the stay-at-home order and that these variations in exposure density had a direct and measurable impact on the risk of infection. Notably, we find that an additional 10% reduction in exposure density city-wide could have saved between 1,849 and 4,068 lives during the study period, predominantly in lower-income and minority communities.

 

Read the Paper

Bias in Smart City Governance

Bias in smart city governance: How socio-spatial disparities in 311 complaint behavior impact the fairness of data-driven decisions

Sustainable Cities and Society

Volume 64, January 2021, 102503

Governance and decision-making in “smart” cities increasingly rely on resident-reported data and data-driven methods to improve the efficiency of city operations and planning. However, the issue of bias in these data and the fairness of outcomes in smart cities has received relatively limited attention. This is a troubling and significant omission, as social equity should be a critical aspect of smart cities and needs to be addressed and accounted for in the use of new technologies and data tools. This paper examines bias in resident-reported data by analyzing socio-spatial disparities in ‘311’ complaint behavior in Kansas City, Missouri. We utilize data from detailed 311 reports and a comprehensive resident satisfaction survey, and spatially join these data with code enforcement violations, neighborhood characteristics, and street condition assessments. We introduce a model to identify disparities in resident-government interactions and classify under- and over-reporting neighborhoods based on complaint behavior. Despite greater objective and subjective need, low-income and minority neighborhoods are less likely to report street condition or “nuisance” issues, while prioritizing more serious problems. Our findings form the basis for acknowledging and accounting for data bias in self-reported data, and contribute to the more equitable delivery of city services through bias-aware data-driven processes.

 

Read More

Energy Cost Burdens

Problem, research strategy, and findings: Of the three primary components of housing affordability measures—rent, transportation, and utilities—utility costs are the least understood yet are the one area where the cost burden can be reduced without household relocation. Existing data sources to estimate energy costs are limited to surveys with small samples and low spatial and temporal resolution, such as the American Housing Survey and the Residential Energy Consumption Survey. In this study, we present a new method for small-area estimates of household energy cost burdens (ECBs) that leverages actual building energy use data for approximately 13,000 multifamily properties across five U.S. cities and links energy costs to savings opportunities by analyzing 3,000 energy audit reports. We examine differentials in cost burdens across household demographic and socioeconomic characteristics and analyze spatial, regional, and building-level variations in energy use and expenditures. Our results show the average low-income household has an ECB of 7%, whereas higher income households have an average burden of 2%. Notably, even within defined income bands, minority households experience higher ECBs than non-Hispanic White households. For lower income households, low-cost energy improvements could reduce energy costs by as much as $1,500 per year.

Takeaway for practice: In this study we attempt to shift the focus of energy efficiency investments to their impact on household cost burdens and overall housing affordability. Our analysis explores new and unique data generated from measurement-driven urban energy policies and shows low-income households disproportionately bear the burden of poor-quality and energy-inefficient housing. Cities can use these new data resources and methods to develop equity-based energy policies that treat energy efficiency and climate mitigation as issues of environmental justice and that apply data-driven, targeted policies to improve quality of life for the most vulnerable urban residents.

Of the three primary components of housing affordability—rent, transportation, and utilities—utility costs are the least understood, despite representing a significant opportunity to improve overall affordability without the need for household relocation (Stone, 2006). Excessive utility expenditures fall disproportionately to the lowest income households, who are least able to make energy efficiency investments, thus raising important social and environmental justice concerns that require policymakers and planners to act (Jenkins, McCauley, Heffron, Stephan, & Rehner, 2016). The slow pace of energy retrofits in existing multifamily buildings highlights the systemic investment constraints that result in an underallocation of energy-efficient technologies in housing (Pivo, 2014). Beyond the potential financial benefits for low-income households, energy-efficient investments can reduce carbon emissions and improve occupant health while achieving long-term sustainability goals (Nevin & Jacobs, 2006; Pearsall & Pierce, 2010). Researchers have made important strides in quantifying the magnitude of energy cost burdens (ECBs) on macro and regional levels, but policymakers and planners lack the granular, high-spatial- and temporal-resolution data needed to develop targeted and proactive policies and programs to directly address this issue. Such policies include incentives and mandates for energy efficiency improvements based on measured energy performance, subsidies for specific energy retrofits tied to building characteristics, and affordable housing programs that integrate rental subsidy amounts with ECB estimates.

In this study we present a new methodology to model household ECBs based on actual energy use data for individual buildings across five major U.S. cities and link energy costs to savings opportunities based on specific residential building types and characteristics. Specifically, we a) use high-resolution data to develop small-area estimates (at the level of individual buildings) of ECBs, b) analyze how ECBs vary by building across demographic and income groups, and c) assess the implications of energy retrofit investments on housing affordability. We examine differentials in ECBs across neighborhoods and socioeconomic groups, comparing lower income and wealthier neighborhoods and analyzing racial disparities within income groups. The data we use in this study consist of actual annual building energy consumption for approximately 13,000 multifamily buildings in New York City (NY), Boston (MA), Cambridge (MA), Seattle (WA), and Washington (DC) reported through city energy disclosure laws. We integrate these data with building and land use characteristics, housing subsidy program information, and socioeconomic characteristics to develop a comprehensive building-level data set of energy use and resident attributes. To analyze the potential financial implications of energy retrofit investments for low-income households, we use a unique data set of energy audit reports for approximately 3,000 residential buildings in New York City to estimate economically and technically feasible energy retrofit opportunities and their impact on ECBs. Although the data we use in this study represent a nonrandom sample of buildings and cities, they nonetheless provide a unique opportunity to develop and demonstrate a new method for planners to leverage large energy data sets to more fully understand household cost burdens at higher spatial and temporal resolutions than are currently possible.

Read the Paper