Paper type: Working Paper

The Comparative Advantage of Cities

What determines the distributions of skills, occupations, and industries across cities? We develop a theory to jointly address these fundamental questions about the spatial organization of economies. Our model incorporates a system of cities, their internal urban structures, and a high-dimensional theory of factor-driven comparative advantage. It predicts that larger cities will be skill-abundant and specialize in skill-intensive activities according to the monotone likelihood ratio property. We test the model using data on 270 US metropolitan areas, 3 to 9 educational categories, 22 occupations, and 21 manufacturing industries. The results provide support for our theory’s predictions.

 

Download PDF

Malthusian Dynamics

The largest cities in the world today lie mainly in relatively poor countries, which is a departure from historical experience, when the largest cities were typically found in the richest places. Further, these poor mega-cities have grown through high rates of urban natural increase, as opposed to the in-migration that drove historical urbanization. In this paper we provide an explanation for the rise of these poor mega-cities and their departure from the historical norms. Combining models of urban agglomeration and congestion with Malthusian models of endogenous population, we show that cities can exert Malthusian forces on living standards. Poor mega-cities have grown because their rapid rate of natural increase exerts a downward force on urban wages, which ensures that natural increase remains high, the megacities remain poor, and their size is unrelated to productivity. In comparison, rich mega-cities of the past had low rates of natural increase, ensuring that they could take advantage of agglomeration technologies, and city growth occurred in response to productivity improvements. Our work shows that Malthusian forces do not disappear just because an economy urbanizes, and that urban Malthusianism combines with rapid urban population growth to drive developing poor mega-cities towards stagnation even if they do not face limits to their resource stocks.

 

Download PDF

Demography, Urbanization and Development

Developing countries have rapidly urbanized since 1950. To explain urbanization, standard models have emphasized rural-urban migration, focusing on rural push factors (agricultural modernization and rural poverty) and urban pull factors (industrialization and urban-biased policies). Using newly compiled historical data on urban birth and death rates for 7 countries from Industrial Europe (1800-1910) and 33 developing countries (1960-2010), we show that a non-negligible part of developing countries’ rapid urban growth and urbanization can also be linked to demographic factors, i.e. rapid internal urban population growth, or an urban push. The much lower urban mortality of today’s developing countries, relative to Industrial Europe, where higher urban death rates virtually offset urban births, has compounded the effects of migration. High urban natural increase, rather than migration, is also found to be associated with urban congestion, thus providing further insight into the phenomenon of urbanization without growth.

 

Download PDF

Cities and the Environment

This paper surveys recent literature examining the relationship between environmental amenities and urban growth. In this survey, we focus on the role of both exogenous attributes such as climate and coastal access as well as endogenous attributes such as local air pollution and green space. A city’s greenness is a function of both its natural beauty and is an emergent property of the types of households and firms that locate within its borders and the types of local and national regulations enacted by voters.

 

We explore four main issues related to sustainability and environmental quality in cities. First, we introduce a household locational choice model to highlight the role that environmental amenities play in shaping where households locate within a city. We then analyze how ongoing suburbanization affects the carbon footprint of cities. Third, we explore how the system of cities is affected by urban environmental amenity dynamics and we explore the causes of these dynamics. Fourth, we review the recent literature on the private costs and benefits of investing in “green” buildings. Throughout this survey, we pay careful attention to empirical research ap- proaches and highlight what are open research questions. While much of the literature focuses on cities in the developed world, we anticipate that similar issues will be of increased interest in developing nation’s cities. 

 

Download PDF

Up or Out?

Co-authored by Jason Krupp and Khyaati Acharya, Up or Out?  Examining the Trade-offs of Urban Form analyses the assumption that in order to accommodate an ever-growing population, cities need to build up, not out. The idea behind this suggestion is that denser, more compact cities achieve higher levels of productivity, greater housing affordability, better health outcomes and less traffic congestion. But do they really?

Research into the historical trends and academic literature on the subject finds the argument for compact cities is far from clear cut. In many cases this urban ideology exacerbates the very problems it looks to solve. Quantitative research reveals US investment in trains has not alleviated traffic congestion, compact cities often have the least affordable housing markets, and urban form changes only have a marginal influence on obesity.

The aim of this report is not to say that rail is not an important part of the urban transport mix, or that suburban housing is preferable to apartments. Rather, the goal is to lay bare the trade-offs that urban residents will have to live with when choosing to adopt a compact city development plan.

 

Download PDF

City Replanning

We provide a new defense for one of the most criticized ideas in land use law, that city plans should constitute settled deals about the proper uses of land that should be sticky against subsequent zoning amendments. This idea was largely rejected by courts and scholars during the 20th century. They argued that parcel-specific zoning amendments lead to the efficient amount of development by encouraging negotiations between developers and residents over externalities from new building projects. Their case against plans suggested that zoning authorities act either as arbiters in land use disputes or as agents for existing residents to encourage negotiated solutions.

We argue that the dismissal of plans has helped contribute to the excessive strictness of zoning in our richest and most productive cities and regions. This in turn has driven up housing prices excessively and produced outcomes that are economically inefficient and distributively unattractive. We argue that plans and comprehensive remappings facilitate trades between city councilmembers who understand the need for new development but refuse to have their neighborhoods be dumping grounds for all new construction. Further, by setting forth what can be constructed as of right, plans reduce the information costs borne by purchasers of land and developers, broadening the market for new construction. We argue that land use law should embrace a version of plans as a procedural tool that packages together policies and sets of zoning changes in a number of neighborhoods simultaneously through procedures that make such packages difficult to unwind.

 

Download PDF

A Seat at the Table

Black plumes of smoke billowing into the sky above New York City. Hundreds of New Yorkers suffering premature deaths annually, with many more visiting emergency rooms or being hospitalized each year. The culprit? Air pollution. To address this environmental and public health threat, the Mayor of New York City launched a visionary effort to improve the city’s air quality. As the focus of that effort narrowed to address a major source of locally generated air pollution — building emissions  — government officials engaged a wide range of stakeholders. Those stakeholders included environmental and health advocates, the real estate and business communities, unions, community-based organizations and academics, who often find themselves isolated from policymaking processes because of time and resource constraints. With environmental and health advocates differing from the real estate and business communities on the best solution to reduce building emissions, academics from New York University shared an important quantitative analysis of an emerging policy proposal with stakeholders. That timely analysis, delivered at a critical juncture in the process, helped inform the outlook of some stakeholders. The narrative that follows is the story of how this policymaking process, and the public-private partnership that evolved from it, helped New York City’s air quality reach the cleanest levels in 50 years and continues to save lives today.

 

Download PDF

Thinking About Punishment

This essay addresses five questions: 

1. What does James Q. Wilson still have to teach us about crime and punishment?

2. What could Wilson have learned from Machiavelli about “cruelty well and badly used”?

3. What conceptual and political errors led to mass incarceration?

4. How do we know that Becker’s rational-actor theory of crime was wrong, and that Beccaria was right about the importance of swiftness and certainty and the inefficacy of severity?

5. Where do we go from here?

 

Download PDF

Decline of Rental Housing in India

Rental housing in India has witnessed a significant decline over the years. This could be attributed to various reasons including the nature of the rent control laws. The rent control law in Mumbai has created a shortfall in formal, affordable rental housing and, at a broader level, has contributed to the distortions in the land market. The nature of the ‘first generation’ rent control in Mumbai is such that it has led to the deterioration of the existing rental housing stock and virtually halted the construction of new housing for rental for the city. It has also given rise to informal practices such as ‘pagdi’ or key money. This paper assesses the impact of rent control for Mumbai. In particular, it analyzes the spatial concentration and composition of rent controlled tenements in the city. It then proposes reforms that would allow a gradual move towards rationalized rent controls. It argues that second generation controls will help incentivize investments in the rental housing segment and hence reduce the demand pressure on the housing market at large, with implications for prices and affordable housing in particular.

 

Download PDF

What Getting Legal Land Title Really Means

This paper documents, for a neighborhood in Ahmedabad, India, what would be involved for current occupants to regularize tenure and register legal title. We show that the process of clearing title can be expensive, fraught with risks, and perhaps impossible to complete for either the current occupants or the owners of record. Staying on the land in their current ambiguous status seems viable for now, but investing in further development is very risky. We discuss these findings in the context of the debate about providing secure tenure to slum dwellers from two perspectives: (i) the practicality of providing legal tenure as part of neighborhood upgrading programs; (ii) the impacts on the real estate market of a system that leaves many private plots, in slums or elsewhere, in legal limbo and difficult to develop—in essence an anti-commons. Both issues are of critical interest as India faces the challenge of urbanization.

 

Download PDF